How Can I Challenge the Results of a Breathalyzer Test in Cook County?

Under Illinois law, specifically 625 ILCS 5/11-501, a person is considered driving under the influence if their blood alcohol content (BAC) is 0.08% or higher. The penalties for DUI convictions vary based on the number of offenses, with increased consequences for repeated offenses, including fines, license suspensions, and jail time.

Breathalyzer tests are a common method for determining BAC in DUI stops. Their results are crucial in the legal process of DUI charges, making their accuracy fundamentally important. However, it's crucial to understand that these tests are not infallible, and there are various circumstances under which their results can be challenged.

The DUI Arrest and Breathalyzer Testing Process

A DUI stop typically begins with a traffic stop where an officer conducts field sobriety tests if they suspect impairment. If these tests suggest intoxication, a breathalyzer test is then administered. This can occur on-site or later at a police station. Following this, the suspect is booked, and additional tests, such as blood tests or a second breath test, may be conducted.

It's important to note that the entire process, from the initial stop to the administration of the breathalyzer test, is subject to strict procedural guidelines. Any deviation from these procedures can potentially be grounds for challenging the test results.

‍

Calibration and Maintenance Issues

Breathalyzers must be properly calibrated and maintained to produce accurate results. If the device was not regularly calibrated or properly maintained, this could lead to inaccurate readings. Legal defenses often successfully challenge breathalyzer results by demonstrating neglect in the device's upkeep.

For example, in Illinois, breathalyzer devices must be certified and calibrated every 62 days. If records show that a device hasn't been calibrated within this timeframe, it could potentially invalidate the test results.

Operator Error

The accuracy of a breathalyzer test also hinges on the operator's proper training and execution. Errors, such as failing to observe the suspect adequately before administering the test or improper testing procedures, can invalidate the results. Highlighting these errors can be a potent defense.

‍

Common operator errors include:

- Failing to observe the subject for the required 20-minute period before the test

- Not properly instructing the subject on how to blow into the device

- Failing to check the subject's mouth for foreign objects or recent regurgitation

‍

Procedural Errors

Adherence to legal procedures is mandatory during DUI stops and tests. Errors like initiating a stop without probable cause or not informing the suspect of their rights can be grounds for dismissing breathalyzer results.

‍

Key procedural requirements include:

- Having probable cause for the initial traffic stop

- Properly advising the suspect of their Miranda rights

- Informing the suspect of the consequences of refusing the test

‍

Medical and Dietary Factors

Certain medical conditions or dietary habits can influence breathalyzer results. Conditions like diabetes or diets that are high in proteins and low in carbohydrates can lead to false positives. These factors can be crucial in contesting DUI charges.

‍

Some specific examples include:

- Gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) can cause the regurgitation of alcohol from the stomach, leading to artificially high readings

- Ketogenic diets can produce acetone on the breath, which some breathalyzers may mistake for alcohol

‍

Environmental Factors

External environmental factors, such as the presence of certain chemicals or variations in temperature and humidity, can affect the accuracy of breathalyzer tests. Identifying these factors can be key in challenging the results.

‍

For instance:

- Paint fumes, gasoline, or other volatile compounds in the environment can interfere with readings

- Extreme temperatures can affect the functionality of breathalyzer devices

‍

Device Malfunctions

Technological faults, including software or hardware malfunctions, can result in erroneous BAC readings. Proving such malfunctions can robustly support a DUI defense.

Recent cases have shown that certain breathalyzer models may have software glitches that can affect their accuracy. Your attorney can investigate whether the specific device used in your case has any known issues or recalls.

‍

There are scenarios where challenging breathalyzer results might not be advisable, such as when BAC readings are significantly above the legal limit or other compelling evidence of impairment exists. In such cases, exploring plea bargains or focusing on other defense strategies may be more advantageous.

‍

The Role of a DUI Defense Attorney in Challenging Breathalyzer Results

Consulting with an experienced DUI attorney is crucial. They can investigate the calibration and maintenance records of the breathalyzer, the qualifications of the operator, and the legality of the DUI arrest process. Early engagement with a lawyer ensures all potential defenses are thoroughly explored.

‍

An experienced attorney will:

- Request and review all relevant documentation related to the breathalyzer device and its maintenance

- Examine the qualifications and training records of the officer who administered the test

- Analyze police reports and video footage for any procedural errors

- Consult with expert witnesses who can testify about the reliability of breathalyzer tests

‍

Implications of a DUI Charge in Cook County, Illinois

The ramifications of a DUI conviction are severe and far-reaching, impacting everything from fines and license suspensions to significant personal and professional consequences.

‍

Potential consequences include:

- First offense: Up to one year in jail, fines up to $2,500, and license suspension for a minimum of one year

- Subsequent offenses: Increased jail time, higher fines, and longer license suspensions

- Professional impacts: Loss of professional licenses, difficulty finding employment

- Personal impacts: Strained relationships, increased insurance rates, and social stigma

‍

Stay informed about recent changes in DUI laws and breathalyzer technology. For instance, some states are now considering the use of more advanced breath testing devices that can detect a wider range of substances. Understanding these developments can be crucial in building an effective defense strategy.

‍

Let’s Review

Understanding how to challenge breathalyzer results is vital for anyone facing a DUI charge in Cook County. Effective challenges can significantly alter the outcome of a case. Remember, while the process may seem daunting, many have successfully navigated these challenges with the right legal support and strategy.

‍

Get the legal help you need

If you're facing DUI charges in Cook County, don't face this challenge alone. Contact Andy Sotiropoulos & Associates for a free consultation. Our focus on DUI defense ensures knowledgeable and dedicated representation. Let us help you understand your options and build a strong defense strategy tailored to your specific situation.

References and Legal Citations

For more information on Cook County DUI laws and breathalyzer test procedures, refer to Illinois Compiled Statutes (625 ILCS 5/11-501) and relevant legal cases such as People v. Orth, 124 Ill. 2d 326 (1988), which established standards for admitting breathalyzer results in cook county, Illinois courts.

‍

This blog is designed to inform and support those facing DUI charges, emphasizing the importance of seasoned legal guidance. Remember, each case is unique, and this information should not be considered as legal advice. Always consult with a qualified attorney to discuss the specifics of your situation.

‍